Interstate disputes resolution in the Caribbean court of justice

• Author: The Hon Justice Duke E.E. Pollard
• Position: Judge, Caribbean Court of Justice
• Pages: 64-80





































 





 





    















    !

""

""



#$%&'



()*++&(,



-#).



-/



#0.*1&

2



-,0*$&)



*,



.3*0



1-,.&4.



.3&



5#$%6&,.



-/



.3&



()*++&(,



-#).



-/



#0.*1&



*,



TLC

v

The

Caribbean

Community



7899:;







8



<='



(

.



>()(



?9

8



3&



0*4



6-$&0



-/



$*0>#.&



)&0-@#.*-,



()&



%--$



-//*1&0



<).



2:2=A



6&$*(.*-,



<)1



2:8=A



1-,0#@.(.*-,0



<

).





2:?=A



1-,1*@*(.*-,



<).0



2:BC89?=A



()+*.)(.*-,



<).0



89DC829=A



(,$



5#$*1*(@



0&..@&6&,.



<).0



822C88?=

I.

Introduction

E&,



.3&



6-0.



1#)0-)F



&4(6*,(.*-,



-/



.3&



*,0.*.#.*-,(@



())(,%&6&,.0



/-)



$*0>#.&0



)&0-@#.*-,



*,



.3&



()*++&(,



-66#,*.F



<()*1-6=



0&.



-#.



*,



*.0



1-,0.*.#&,.



*,0.)#6&,.



G-#@$



1-,/*)6



.3(.



.3&0&



())(,%&6&,.0



()&



*,1-,.)-E&).*+@F



.(.&C



-)*&,.&$





,



.3*0



1-,.&4.'



3(>.&)



*,&



-/



.3&



&E*0&$



)&(.F



-/



3(%#()(6(0



0.(+@*03*,%



.3&



()*++&(,



-66#,*.F



,1@#$*,%



.3&



()*1-6



*,%@&



H()I&.



(,$



1-,-6F



<.3&



&E*0&$



)&(.F=



($$)&00&0



$*0>#.&0



0&..@&6&,.



*,



()*1-6





).*1@&



2JK



-/



.3&



&E*0&$



)&(.F



*$&,.*/*&0



*,



(



,-,C&43(#0.*E&



6(,,&)



/-#)



$*01)&.&



0*.#(.*-,0



*,



G3*13



(@@&%(.*-,0



-/



$&E*(,.



1-,$#1.



6(F



%*E&



)*0&



.-



$*0>#.&0



1-,1&),*,%



.3&



*,.&)>)&.(.*-,



(,$



(>>@*1(.*-,



-/



.3&



&E*0&$



)&(.F



,



&(13



-/



.3&0&



0*.#(.*-,0



.(.&



>().*&0



()&'



+F



1-6>&@@*,%



*,/&)&,1&'



G*.3*,



.3&



1-,.&6>@(.*-,



-/



1-6>&.&,.



$&1*0*-,C6(I&)0



(0



>)*,1*>(@



@*.*%(,.0

2



*6*@()@F



*.



$-&0



(>>&()



.-



+&



.3&



0#+5&1.



-/



(



)&(0-,(+@&



*,/&)&,1&



.3(.



.(.&0



G-#@$



+&



.3&



>)*,1*>(@



$*0>#.(,.0



*,



)&0-).*,%



.-



.3&



0*4



6-$&0



-/



$*0>#.&



)&0-@#.*-,



*$&,.*/*&$



*,



).*1@&



2JJL



3&



G*$&



)(,%&



-/



->.*-,0



(//-)$&$



.(.&



>().*&0



&,%(%&$



*,



$*0>#.&0



1-6>@*(,1&



())(,%&6&,.0



3-@$



-#.



,-



>@(#0*+@&



%#()(,.&&



.3(.



-,&



-)



(,-.3&)



6-$&



G-#@$



1-66&,$



*.0&@/



.-



$*0>#.(,.0



*,



.3&



&E-@E*,%



()*1-6



*,%@&



H()I&.



(,$



1-,-6F



<H=

&0>*.&



.3&



.(.&C-)*&,.&$



+*(0



-/



.3&



$*0>#.&0



1-6>@*(,1&



)&%*6&



-/



()*1-6'



.G-



1-,0*$&)(.*-,0



6(F



->&)(.&



.-



03*/.



.3&



/-1#0



.-G()$0



.3&



(1.*E&



>().*1*>(.*-,



-/



>)*E(.&



&,.*.*&0'



*,$*)&1.@F



.3)-#%3



.3&



-66#,*.F



(,$



$*)&1.@F



+F



.3&



*,*.*(.*-,



-/



$*0>#.&0



1-6>@*(,1&



>)-1&&$*,%0



+F



>)*E(.&



&,.*.*&0



,





>(>&)



>)&0&,.&$



(.



.3&



)(,$&*0



,0.*.#.&



/-)



,.&),(.*-,(@



#$%&0



-,/&)&,1&



899:'



-).



-/



>(*,'



)*,*$($



(,$



-+(%-'



BCJ



(,#()F'



899: