Aspects of judicial independence and accountability - lessons for the Commonwealth Caribbean
| Author | Sir David Simmons |
| Position | Formerly Chief Justice of Barbados |
| Pages | 88-112 |
!
"
#
$
"
!%&
!%
"
'
()
&!
'
*+
, -.'
*//+0
!-1
"%
( &
!%
.!0
#
Fragile
Bastion
–
Judicial
Independence
in
the
Nineties
and
Beyond
–
,(.& !
!%
"
(&
!--!
!%
2
!( "
3#+445'
"0
#'
*0
67
8 9 6:
6; ;< = >
"
,,
"
- -!,"!
!
!-
"
10
-!
&
%!-
'
,(."
"'
2
!
"
#$
"
!%&
!%
"
"
()
&!
!
*+
, -.'
*//+0
(
2
1
?'
2!
1
?!'
!
&&,
"
!
!%
"
!
!%
"
Caribbean
Law
Review
!
!%%
!
%!
&(!
"
(
&
!
!%!
.
@!0
2
2 "
&
?
!%
%%&
"
!'
)!2?
"
2!(
!?
"
&! .( !
!%
! "
%
-!
"
0
"'
"'
"
.&)?!('
.(
!
!
"
!
,
!2
2"
2!
"
!%
.
@!0
"
2!
1
&)!2?-
!%
"
.
2"&"
!2
!%!
@!
%!
"
-1
21
2"&"
"
!
!%
A
-1
!2
-
& (
"!B!0
&! .( !
!
"
&,
!%
2
"
!--!2 "
..
"
.
-
% ?
"
.
&!?
"
,(.& !
!%
1
"
"!!(0
"
(
!2
2
"0
!-
1
?!0
"!1
!'
%!-
"%
( &
!%
( '
2
"
C
%(
!
)
"
?"
.&
. 2
@(&
,&
@(&
&&!( . 1
2
(
"
(&&, .
2)?
!%
@(&
,&
!
D(
&&!( . 10
E
#
"
,,
A-
!-
!%
"
!?
,&
!%
@(&
,&
@(&
&&!( . 1
2 "
!(
"
!--!2 "
..
"?"?"
!-
!%
"
,& &
,!.-
2"&"
!&&(
!(
?!
!
Aspects
of
Judicial
Independence
and
Accountability
89
)1
&!
0
&!
!%
&!(
.(
-??
,& &
! "
,
!%
"
!--!2 "
,!
A&
?(&
!
%!
(
"
..
0
(&
,&
&&!( . 1
!
! &
-
0
"1
,&,
2"&"'
- 1'
-1
!
, &(1
2 "
@(&
!%%&
.&(
"1
!
%%&
"-
,& &
21
0
(
"1
,&,
2"&"
%(-
!
?!!
?!&
-!& &
!& 0
'
!--!2 "
!%
F!-
&)!2?
"
-,! &
!%
"
2!
,&,
2"'
"
- ?
.(@'
?
3*//G5
"1
!,
"
-
!(
F(
*
Commonwealth
Principles
.
(&"
-,! &
,&
!2
&&!
@(&
,&
"
"
H
-
& (1
"
"
,&,
"
A
!%
"
! ( !
%!-
&
*//$
0
G
*
"
-
!(
F(
%!
"
!--!2 "'
#+
('
#++I0
G
& !
G3#50
J
K*//#L
*
G
0
$
,0
#/I
#/+
0
"!(?"
"
,,
2
&(
@(&
,&
&&!( . 1
, 1'
2
.
?(
"
"
2!
&!&,
!
&!
-(
&!A M
"
@(&1
&!
%
!
(?!.
.(
-(
.
&&!( .
!
"
! "
.&"
!%
?!-
!
"
,!,0
-
.?
"
&(!
2 "
.%
A- !
!%
"
!
!%
"
@(?0
!%
"
.
&, !
)!2
"
!%
F! "
"
&!
!%
"
(,-
!(
!%
Thierren
v
Canada
(Minister
of
Justice)
.
J
"
"
N
"
@(&
%(& !
.!( 1
(D(0
(
!& 1
?
-,!
,!2
,!.
!
"
--.
!%
@(&10
,
%!-
"
!
!
!%
.
2"&"
,(
@(&
. 2
"
?"
!%
"
, '
@(?
!
,!.
%!
,?
"
.&
!%
&! ( !
,!2
O
( "-!'
%!!2?
"
& -
!%
"
" '
"1
"
.&!-
!
!%
"
%!-!
%
!%
(
%!-
"(-
?"
?(
!%
"
(
-.!000
&&!?1'
%!-
"
,!
!%
2
!%
"
(
2"!
,,
.%!
"-'
@(?
&
%
%!-!
"
!
2"!
"
2
'
?
"
,!
?"
!
-,!
!.? !
!
"-
!
"0
%
2
"
!!)
.1!
"
@(
!
2"!-
2
?
,!. 1
%!
!?
&!%&
. 2
, '
@(?
!
,1
%(-
!
"
1
!%
"
A
!.
!%
"
@(&
1 -0
"
@(?
"
,
!%
!(
@( &
1 -'
!%
"
?"
%!-
2"&"
"
1 -
?
!
,!-!
,! & P
To continue reading
Request your trial